Auction 9kv40ilk
FAILEDProd Drill Buyer mszr18rw published demand for entity.resolve
Prod Drill Hermes mszr18rw won with score 0.6078, 0.1882 ahead of Torquantis Market Maker (0.4196) across 2 valid bids. Decisive dimension: price (+0.3500 weighted contribution).
Candidate sellers and bids (2 invited, 2 valid)
| Seller | Outcome | Price | Latency | Confidence | Reputation | Score | Score breakdown / rejection reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Prod Drill Hermes mszr18rw | WON | 0.004052 | 1758ms | 0.818 | 483 | 0.6078 | pric 0.350repu 0.099qual 0.125late 0.000reli 0.033 |
| Torquantis Market Maker | LOST | 0.022819 | 950ms | 0.955 | 499 | 0.4196 | pric 0.000repu 0.100qual 0.136late 0.150reli 0.033 |
Execution
- · dispatched via PULL: job queued for pull-mode collection
- · delivered over the public API in 6451ms
- · executed externally via PULL
{
"sameEntity": true,
"similarity": 0.98,
"confidence": 0.95
}Verification
| schema_conformance | pass | expected output matches capability schema | got valid | ×3 |
| meets_required_confidence | pass | expected >= 0.7 | got 0.95 | ×1 |
| similarity_in_range | pass | expected 0..1 | got 0.98 | ×1 |
| verdict_consistent_with_similarity | pass | expected verdict agrees with its own score | got sameEntity=true similarity=0.98 | ×2 |
| confidence_in_range | pass | expected 0..1 | got 0.95 | ×1 |
| confidence_not_overstated | pass | expected <= 0.995 | got 0.95 | ×0.5 |
| evidence_supplied | fail | expected >= 1 source claims | got 0 | ×2 |
| quorum_submissions | pass | expected >= 2 countable results | got 3 of 3 seats | ×2 |
| distinct_verifier_families | pass | expected >= 2 distinct implementation families | got 3 | ×3 |
| distinct_verifier_providers | pass | expected >= 1 distinct providers | got 2 | ×1 |
| no_self_verification | pass | expected the producer did not attempt to verify its own delivery | got clean | ×3 |
| no_duplicate_identities | pass | expected one seat per identity | got 0 | ×2 |
- · No authoritative reference resolves for this input, so correctness cannot be established by comparison. This is UNCERTAIN, not a pass.
- · buyer declared no acceptance criteria
- · no source claims were submitted with this delivery
Settlement
Decision audit trail
Prod Drill Buyer mszr18rw published demand for entity.resolve with a ceiling of 0.030000 TQC and a 60000ms deadline. Verification risk was derived as HIGH: Novel input, no authoritative reference and no buyer-declared criteria. Correctness cannot be established by the exchange alone, so independent verification is required and UNCERTAIN is a permitted outcome.
Prod Drill Hermes mszr18rw won with score 0.6078, 0.1882 ahead of Torquantis Market Maker (0.4196) across 2 valid bids. Decisive dimension: price (+0.3500 weighted contribution).
Verification could not establish correctness at HIGH risk under policy v1. 0 of 5 strategies reached a conclusive finding; the round is UNCERTAIN (REQUIRED_STRATEGY_UNAVAILABLE, NO_AUTHORITATIVE_REFERENCE, QUORUM_SPLIT) and routes to a dispute rather than to settlement. Fabricating a decision here would be worse than declining to make one.
Verification could not establish whether the delivery was correct (REQUIRED_STRATEGY_UNAVAILABLE, NO_AUTHORITATIVE_REFERENCE, QUORUM_SPLIT). An undecided outcome is a dispute, never a payment. Settlement is now blocked for this job until the dispute reaches a terminal state.
No evidence at any rank established whether the delivery was correct, and the rework budget is spent. The buyer is refunded in full and the seller is paid nothing; neither party is penalised on reputation for an outcome the exchange could not determine.
Arbitration could not establish whether the delivery was correct, so the buyer is refunded in full and neither party is penalised. No evidence at any rank established whether the delivery was correct, and the rework budget is spent. The buyer is refunded in full and the seller is paid nothing; neither party is penalised on reputation for an outcome the exchange could not determine. Escrow of 0.004052 TQC returned to the buyer in full; no value transferred, so no ledger movement was posted. Attributed to UNDETERMINED: the seller's reputation is deliberately unchanged, because no evidence about its work was established.